wet n wildColor Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Rich Hyper-Pigmented Color, Smooth Creamy Application, Long-Wearing Matte Finish Versatility, Cruelty-Free - Baby's Got Black

Went on very nicely and super simple, easy to smudge, and a bit hard to wash off. Very nice eye liner! Size is like the average school pencil, texture is smooth, and it has great pigment. You get a very good product for what you pay for.

This kohl eye liner pencil is great! Glides on easily and doesn'tbreak like most pencils do. The color is a true black and lastsall day..washes off easily with a bit of baby oil. Highly recommend !

These are great. The pigment in these is amazing. I bought these in dark brown. I love them super creamy going on. They stay on great price point.

I included two pictures with this product (outside and inside) vs with a liquid eyeliner. I feel more comfortable with a stick eyeliner than a liquid eyeliner for application, and the quality is long lasting and thick. The glide works great with short strokes and the size is thicker and better than small liquid eyeliner strokes. Ultimately, this is a great, cheap, and easy eyeliner to use!

Brightness was great. As someone who loves black, it glided on just the way I needed it to and show that pop-up color. It lasts a long time and it’s pretty easy to wear. The size is good as long as you sharpen it. And pretty easy removal I would recommend it.

3 stars because how I feel about these liners depends on my intended purpose. Using these as a brow pencil is amazing for me and I love using Pretty In Mink on my brows. I have greyish brown brows since I have bronde hair and using PIM makes them actually visible. I loveee it as an eyebrow pencil. No issues on my brows. As an eyeliner? Well, keep reading…I bought two of these liners: the black and the white and I so badly wish these stayed put. I tried using these multiple times, even thinking maybe if I waited a few months the formula would become less smudgy somehow. They smudge and run from my eyes within ten minutes. I’ve never been a make up snob, hence why I was down for a $1 eyeliner. I know sometimes you can find a steal for $1. With these, specifically the black color, they just smudge on my eyes so fast. I probably wouldn’t mention it if it ran after a couple hours or something after being out all day. I ended up giving the black one to my mom who doesn’t have oily eyelids whatsoever. I hope it works for her but this brand left me disappointed and looking crusty. Very easy to apply but also unfortunately very easy to smudge and run.

I used this eyeliner pencil as a lip liner and it worked perfectly! Super smooth, easy to blend, and the color payoff is amazing. Stayed on for hours too. Definitely a hack I’ll keep using!

I really like the Pretty in Mink color. It's as dark brown as you can get without being black. It does melt a little on the eyelid but I'm going to try an eye primer underneath. Either way you can't beat the price and I LOVE the color.